US state of Florida says no to lab-grown meat

TALLAHASSEE: United States’s (US) Republican-led state Florida enacted legislation banning the manufacture and distribution of lab-grown meat, making it the first state to do so.

Florida’s Governor Ron DeSantis signed the bill “Senate Bill 1084 (2024)” into law in Wauchula. The law was reportedly implemented to “safeguard” the state’s cattle industry.

Read more: Several meat sellers held for overpricing in Bannu

Lab-grown meat or “cultured meat” is produced from animal stem cells. It has been hailed as an alternative to traditional meat since its production methods are a huge strain on the environment. The cattle industry alone contributes heavily to the climate change with cows releasing tonnes of methane into Earth’s atmosphere every year.

Lab-grown meat potentially addresses environmental and ethical concerns linked with conventional meat production. However, its economic and environmental impact still raises questions. Tests have also indicated that people dislike the taste of lab-grown meat.

Meanwhile, critics of the new law argue that it stifles innovation and may deter investment in the emerging industry. Several questions have been raised on the necessity of such legislation. Florida already has a thriving meat industry and there is a lack of significant market competition.

Lab-grown meat has received regulatory approval from the country’s Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Department of Agriculture (USDA). However, there are concerns regarding its safety and labeling practices.

The meat alternative has also faced targeted disinformation campaign. Debunked rumours surrounding lab-grown meat include misconceptions about its origin, labeling, and health implications.

The ban in Florida reflects broader debates surrounding the regulation and acceptance of lab-grown meat as a viable alternative to traditional meat. Similar measures have been considered in other states, including Alabama, Arizona, and Tennessee, though no other state has yet implemented such legislation.

Florida’s ban on lab-grown meat also raises economic implications and sparks contention. Proponents argue that it protects existing industries, while others suggest it may hinder technological advancement and market competition.

The new law also raised questions about consumer choice and the role of government intervention in regulating emerging industries in a free and open market.