Gone too far? social media urges PCB to reconsider Rs20m fine on Naseem Shah’s tweet

Pakistani fast bowler Naseem Shah has sparked widespread debate online after the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) imposed a Rs20 million fine over a social media post targeting Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz.

Users on X and other platforms expressed mixed reactions, with some criticising Shah’s post and others questioning the severity of the penalty. The tweet, which has since been deleted, questioned the protocol extended to Maryam Nawaz during the Pakistan Super League’s opening ceremony at Lahore’s Gaddafi Stadium, asking, “Why is she treated like the queen at Lord’s?”

Shah later clarified that his account had been hacked, stating, “This account of Naseem was recently hacked but now recovered successfully.” The PCB had initially issued a show-cause notice, citing possible violations of Shah’s central contract and the board’s media policy, and requested a formal response within a specified timeframe.

While Shah has issued an apology, he has not commented further on the matter. The Rs20 million fine underlines the PCB’s strict approach toward player conduct on social media, reminding athletes of the responsibilities tied to their public profiles.

The controversy has dominated cricket circles and online discussions, particularly as it coincided with a high-profile PSL event attended by political figures. Many fans weighed in on the balance between personal expression and professional responsibility, making the incident a trending topic across Pakistan’s social media landscape.

By apologising, Shah appears to be aiming to move past the controversy, but the fine remains a significant statement from the PCB about the standards expected from players both on and off the field.

Some however felt that the timing of Shah’s apology tweet implied that he only did so after the fine was slapped.