MDCAT result validity issues spark fresh debate among students and policymakers

Students across Pakistan are raising urgent questions about the validity of MDCAT results, as inconsistencies and unclear rules continue to fuel confusion and stress. Every year, over 200,000 candidates sit the Medical and Dental College Admission Test (MDCAT), but the lack of a unified national policy on result validity has left many unsure about their future.

In recent weeks, candidates have taken to social media, organised campaigns, and submitted formal appeals demanding clarity. Many argue that the one-year validity rule is unrealistic, particularly for students unable to secure admission in their first attempt. They are calling for an extension of at least two years, citing financial pressures, academic delays, and the acceptance of longer validity periods in several other countries.

Private colleges, public rules and rising concerns

Adding to the confusion, some private medical colleges have been accepting MDCAT scores from previous years, contradicting Pakistan Medical and Dental Council’s official one-year guideline. This has created merit disparities and intensified frustration among students trying to navigate the admissions process fairly.

Repeat candidates face mounting psychological pressure, including family expectations, additional tuition costs, and fear of wasting another year. Advocates say longer validity could reduce stress and allow better planning for students across Pakistan.

Despite repeated verbal assurances from PMDC, no written policy has been issued. Students continue to call for an official notification to clarify the rules for all future admissions cycles.

Parliamentary panel calls for urgent reforms

Earlier this week, the National Assembly Standing Committee on National Health Services, Regulations and Coordination reviewed growing concerns over MDCAT result validity issues. Chaired by MNA Mahesh Kumar Malani, the committee discussed the inconsistent acceptance of results across provinces, rising vacant MBBS and BDS seats, and challenges with IBCC equivalency for Cambridge-system students.

The Health Minister acknowledged that current admissions could not be retroactively changed but promised to consider legislative amendments. A legally vetted plan is expected from PMDC, the Law Division, and university vice chancellors within two days to prevent further seat wastage.

Committee members also addressed administrative irregularities at the Pakistan Nursing and Midwifery Council and rising concerns over DRAP oversight and pharmacy referrals near federal hospitals.

With students demanding transparency and uniform rules, the MDCAT result validity issue remains a pressing challenge, affecting both candidates’ futures and the broader medical education system in Pakistan.