Fatima Asghar case: Islamabad court orders probe into child labour, FIA officer’s role


  • Ali Hamza
  • November 20, 2026
Representational image of a judge holding a gavel. — AFP/FILE

ISLAMABAD: An Islamabad court on Friday directed police to investigate possible child labour and exploitation in the death of 13-year-old Fatima Asghar, while examining the role of a Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) officer at whose official residence she had lived for nearly three years.

When police registered a murder case over Fatima’s death six days ago, the first information report (FIR) named no suspect. Her father told police that she had been living with relatives at a residence in Police Lines, H-11, Islamabad, where she was also memorising the Quran at a madrassa.

He said he had been informed that Fatima suddenly fell ill and died after being taken to hospital. Marks of violence were subsequently found on her body. However, the FIR did not identify the relatives, explain why a girl from Rahim Yar Khan was living with them, or establish what she was doing at the house and how she sustained her injuries.

The residence belonged to Muhammad bin Ashraf, a police service officer serving as FIA director in Gujranwala. On November 15, the day the FIR was registered, the agency recalled him to its headquarters without giving a reason. His wife, Afshan Ali, is among the two accused in the case. Ashraf has not been named as an accused.

Police have told the court that they recovered an electric iron and a wooden stick, commonly known as a danda, from Afshan, and another stick from the second accused, Ali Raza.

On Friday, Islamabad Judicial Magistrate Naima Iffat directed investigators to examine the questions left unanswered in the FIR.

She extended the physical remand of Afshan and Ali Raza, an employee of the Punjab Highway Patrol who also worked as domestic help at the residence, by three days.

In an order outlining 13 points for the investigating officer, the magistrate directed police to establish the circumstances surrounding Fatima’s stay at the house, the arrangements under which she was handed over to the family and the responsibilities of those entrusted with her care.

How Fatima ended up at the house

The magistrate first directed investigators to establish Fatima’s circumstances when she arrived at the residence.

According to the FIR, her father handed her over to the accused family nearly three years ago, when she was around 10, on the understanding that they were relatives and would arrange for her education.

However, Iffat noted that the case record “does not presently contain material” to substantiate these claims.

She directed the investigating officer to establish Fatima’s exact age at the time through her birth registration and National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) records. Police must also verify the claimed family relationship through documentary evidence rather than relying solely on statements.

Investigators have further been asked to determine the actual purpose of the handover and whether any arrangement existed for Fatima’s education, upkeep or welfare.

Her schooling, including the Quran memorisation mentioned in the FIR, must also be verified through admission registers and attendance records.

FIA officer’s role under scrutiny

The order also focuses on the circumstances in which Fatima spent nearly three years at the official residence of Muhammad bin Ashraf.

The investigating officer has been directed to establish why she was brought to the house, what services she was expected to provide and whether she was made to perform domestic work or subjected to any form of child labour or exploitation.

The magistrate specifically directed police to investigate Ashraf’s role, including what he knew about Fatima’s presence at his official residence, why she was kept there, how she was treated and the circumstances surrounding her death.

His “individual role and possible liability”, the order states, must be assessed independently on the basis of evidence.

Father’s role also to be examined

The magistrate also directed investigators to examine Fatima’s father’s conduct during the three years she lived away from him.

Police must establish whether he remained in contact with his daughter, visited her, sent money for her upkeep or otherwise showed concern for her welfare.

The investigation must also determine why he handed over a 10-year-old child to the household, whether he received money or any other benefit in return, and whether he knowingly allowed her to be employed as domestic help or exploited.

His possible liability under Section 328-A of the Pakistan Penal Code, which deals with cruelty to a child, must also be examined.

To establish the circumstances of Fatima’s stay, the magistrate directed police to record statements from household staff who worked at the residence during the relevant period, as well as neighbours and others familiar with her presence and treatment.

All witnesses must be examined and their statements recorded in accordance with the law. Investigators must also establish the individual role of each accused, as well as any other person who may have been involved in the alleged torture, ill-treatment, wilful neglect or exploitation that led to her death.

Medical and forensic evidence

The magistrate directed police to collect and preserve all medical and forensic evidence relating to Fatima’s death.

This includes details of every injury, expert opinions on the cause and manner of death, the approximate age of the injuries and their possible connection with her death. Chemical and histopathology examinations have also been ordered.

The investigating officer has further been asked to determine whether Sections 328 and 328-A of the Pakistan Penal Code and Section 3 of the Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT) Domestic Workers Act, 2022, apply to the case, along with any other offences established by the evidence.

The ICT Domestic Workers Act prohibits the employment of children as domestic workers in the capital.

Iffat also referred investigators to the Supreme Court’s judgment in Raja Khurram Ali Khan v. The State (PLD 2020 SC 146), commonly known as the Tayyaba case. In that case, a judge and his wife were convicted over the abuse of their 10-year-old domestic worker.

The magistrate emphasised that the investigation “is not confined to the sections in the FIR” and must be conducted “fairly, independently and without influence of the social, financial or official position of any party”.

A copy of the order was also sent to the District and Sessions Judge (West).

‘Physical torture’

“The medical evidence prima facie indicates that the deceased sustained multiple injuries and died allegedly as a consequence of physical torture,” the magistrate wrote.

The observation marks the first time a court has explicitly referred to physical torture in connection with the circumstances of Fatima’s death.

The electric iron and wooden sticks are listed in the police remand application as recovered weapons. Police have said both accused were arrested after investigators examined CCTV footage, which has since been seized along with the recording device.

The evidence presented by police also includes the postmortem and inquest reports, witness statements, Fatima’s B-form and her medical record from Quaid-e-Azam International Hospital.

Fatima was initially taken to the hospital before being shifted to the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS) for an initial medical examination.

The magistrate’s order does not disclose the postmortem findings. Hospital sources had earlier said the initial examination revealed more than 20 injuries, some old and some healed, as well as burn marks and a blood clot on her head.

In court

Afshan was produced before the court in the custody of a female inspector, while Ali Raza, son of Abdul Ghaffar, was also brought before the magistrate. Defence counsel appeared for the accused, while Deputy District Public Prosecutor Wajid Ali represented the state.

Police had requested a further four days of physical remand. Iffat found reasonable grounds for extending the custody but described the requested period as “excessive”, granting three days instead.

On November 16, police had sought eight days of physical remand, but the magistrate had granted four.

Both accused have been directed to appear before the court again on November 23, along with a progress report on the investigation.

You May Also Like

WhatsApp