‘Hang whoever issued it’: IHC chief justice lashes out at CDA over 60-year-old land dues


  • Ali Hamza
  • November 17, 2026
A view of the Islamabad High Court's building. IHC WEBSITE/FILE

ISLAMABAD: Islamabad High Court (IHC) Chief Justice Sarfraz Dogar on Tuesday lashed out at the Capital Development Authority (CDA) for failing to implement a court order on rehabilitation benefits for families whose land was acquired by the authority more than six decades ago. He gave the CDA 15 days to submit a compliance report and indicated that its chairman could be summoned in person.

Hearing contempt petitions filed by Muhammad Shareef and others of Sohan village, the chief justice took exception when the petitioners’ counsel said the CDA had summoned his clients to its own hearing that same day, though the matter was pending in court.

“When the court’s order had already come, why is the CDA holding a hearing?” the chief justice asked. “We overlook one thing and another problem of yours comes up. This is exactly how you are disrespecting the court’s order.”

When the CDA’s counsel said the order in question had been issued by the authority’s DC, the chief justice shot back: “Whoever issued the order, hang him on my behalf.”

“I no longer want to hear what is true and what is false. I want implementation of the court’s order,” he said.

The court adjourned the hearing for 15 days, directing the CDA to submit an implementation report in the main case. The separate contempt case against CDA Member (Estate) Muhammad Zaman Watto would be taken up later, the chief justice said.

The missed appearance

According to court orders, Watto was directed on June 15, 2026 to appear in person. On September 16, he did not show up, and an adjournment was sought on his behalf on the ground that he was unwell.

At the next hearing, on September 23, the petitioners’ counsel placed on record an attested order from the court of Justice Inaam Ameen Minhas showing that Watto had marked his attendance there on the very same day. The chief justice issued him a contempt notice and appointed a prosecutor.

In his written reply, Mr Watto tendered an unconditional apology. He said he was in Justice Minhas’s court, where the CDA chairman had been summoned in another petition, and by the time he was relieved the chief justice’s proceedings had ended. He denied authorising anyone to say he was ill. Deputy Director (Land) Riaz Khan also denied telling the court the member was unwell.

The court was not persuaded. In a November 3 order, the chief justice found the reply “unsatisfactory”, calling it “merely an attempt to controvert the allegations”. He fixed the matter, now registered as The State vs Muhammad Zaman Watto, for framing of charge.

Six decades of waiting

At the heart of the dispute are rehabilitation plots owed to families whose land was acquired for the capital.

Talking to Hum News, petitioners’ counsel Barrister Husnain Haider Thaheem said: “This petition was filed regarding the rehabilitation benefit as per the Rehabilitation Policy 1996, and the land was acquired in 1964. It has been almost five to six decades and yet, due to the bureaucratic and lethargic approach of the CDA, the rehabilitation benefit could not be extended to the original affectees of the CDA.”

“This is the third round of litigation by the petitioner before the Islamabad High Court, and in the previous two rounds the CDA candidly admitted the stance of the petitioner and solicited one month’s time for completion of codal formalities, but unfortunately it could not be completed as of yet,” he said.

Court records back the account of earlier undertakings. On January 29, 2026, the high court disposed of an earlier contempt petition after CDA counsel Muhammad Nazir Jawad stated the grievance would be decided within a month and the petitioners’ names processed for NADRA e-balloting.

In his reply to the contempt notice, Mr Watto said “certain irregularities” had been identified in the allotment of rehabilitation plots but that the petitioners’ cases had been finalised and plots would be allotted through NADRA e-balloting “within a period of one month”.

The CDA did not respond to multiple requests for comment before this story was filed.

You May Also Like

WhatsApp